Link - article by Simon Rose and Avi Abrams

Perpetual Futility, or Triumph of Imagination?

Perpetual motion is a term used to describe a machine that can operate indefinitely. It is also sometimes used to define a device that produces more energy than it uses, no matter how long it is able to operate. Most scientists and scholars agree that perpetual motion violates either the first or second law of thermodynamics or in fact breaks both of them. Some devices which don’t break these laws but get their energy from an obscure source have been called perpetual motion machines, but really aren’t.

(left: Perpetual Motion patent Model 1900-1905, via; right: impossible flying contraption)

In terms of the laws of physics, at least as we understand them in the early twenty first century, perpetual motion machines are impossibilities. However, a wide variety of machines, theories and devices have been developed and proposed over the years. Here’s a look at some of the more interesting ones here at Dark Roasted Blend.

(left image courtesy of EMS Exhibits, Vienna; right: Reidar Finsrud Perpetual motion machine, read below)

(left: typical "perpetual" water wheel and pump, via; right: waterwheel clock via)

Bhaskara’s wheel dates from the mid-twelfth century and was invented in India by the mathematician Bhaskara. The wheel’s curved or tilted spokes were partially filled with mercury. Once the wheel started spinning, mercury flowed across the spoke and the wheel would continue spinning, for a while at least.

(images via 1, 2)

The Bibliotheque Nationale in Paris houses the drawings of Villard de Honnecourt, which date from the middle of the thirteenth century. His sketches feature various lifting devices, a water-powered saw, examples of automata and a perpetual-motion machine, although it’s not clear if de Honnecourt designed any of these himself or was describing objects he’d seen on his travels around Europe:

(images credit: History of Computers)

Also in France, in 1269 Petrus Peregrinus de Maricourt devised one of the earliest perpetual motion machines making use of magnets. The toothed wheel passes close to a lodestone. The teeth are thus repelled by one pole then attracted by the other one, maintaining the motion (left image below):

(images via 1, 2)

Right image above: Mariano di Jacopo detto il Taccola was an Italian artist and engineer working in the early Renaissance. His technological writings are filled with drawings of proposals for machinery and devices. This wheel is from the early decades of fifteenth century. Here is another great image of perpetual wheel - click here.

Robert Fludd’s Water Screw from 1618 was designed for driving millstones. This was probably the first time someone had tried to show how a perpetual motion machine might be able to do something that was actually useful (left image below):

(images via 1, 2, 3)

From later in the seventeenth century, we have this apparently self-flowing flask invented by Robert Boyle (top right image above). It looks as if it refills itself using siphon action, although a siphon’s input is usually higher than the output, so this doesn’t strictly fit the accepted perpetual motion criteria.

Also in the image above (bottom right) you can see Edward Leedskalnin's magnetic generator, part of his Perpetual Motion Holder research.

(left image via, right via)

Right image above: A late 17th-century version of Fludd's perpetual motion machine grinding grain as shown in Böckler's Theatre of New Machines (Image courtesy of the University of Kentucky's Special Collections Library).

In Germany in the early eighteenth century, Johann Bessler built Orffyreus’s Wheel, that he claimed was self-moving. At the time, following a great number of tests and official inspections, it was thought to have been the genuine article. Apparently it could do heavy work and even ran for fifty four days in one test. Today, experts don’t consider the wheel to have been capable of perpetual motion, but even now, apart from the fact that the wheel was known to have used weights in some way, no one really agrees on what might have been the power source for Orffyreus’s Wheel:

(image via Bessler Wheel)

A so-called generator invented in Philadelphia in 1812 by Charles Redheffer was supposed to be able to power other machinery. However, it was exposed as a fraud when it was discovered that the device was secretly connected to another machine in an adjoining room (left image)...Right image: Sir William Congreve designed this device, which was believed to be capable of perpetual motion, in 1827:

(images via 1, 2)

The Crookes Radiometer, also called the light mill, was invented in 1873 by chemist Sir William Crookes. The glass bulb contains a partial vacuum and vanes on the spindle. These spin when exposed to light, increasing in speed with the brightness of the light and scientists have long debated what causes the rotation:

(images via AcumenLabWare, 2)

James Cox invented a clock called Cox’s Timepiece in the 1760’s. Although heralded as a perpetual motion machine, the clock’s power source is actually derived from changes in the planet’s atmospheric pressure, using a mercury barometer. It works in much the same manner as other mechanical clocks, except that it doesn’t need winding. The first clocks powered by atmospheric fluctuations date from the early seventeenth century and one was owned by England’s King James I:

(images via 1, 2)

On the right is James Cox's famous Peacock Clock displayed in Hermitage Museum, Russia.

John Joseph Merlin worked with James Cox on "perpetual motion machine". This is a replica of Merlin's 1776 Band Clock, made by Trevor Beatson of Calgary, Canada, which won a gold medal from the National Association of Watch and Clock Collectors:

(images via 1, 2)

Atmos is a well known brand of mechanical clock first produced in Switzerland by Jean-Leon Reutter in 1928. Like Cox’s timepiece, the clocks are powered by environmental changes and don’t need to be wound manually, often running continuously for years:

(images via 1, 2, 3, 4)

Here we have the Reidar Finsrud perpetual motion machine, in which a collection of magnets are employed to attract a steel ball. Apparently, it hasn’t been determined just how this thing can actually work, since the only energy sources are the magnets. In theory, it might be able to run for years or decades and could be an excellent source of electricity, who knows? -

(images via)

Several ‘free energy’ machines are supposed to have been developed by engineer John Bedini. However, these devices have not been officially investigated by independent scientists. This site has some schematics available as a "gift to the people":

(images via 1, 2)

Back in 1934, this monstrosity rail car ran on "air-electric perpetual drive" (more info):

(image via)

This is the N1 Homopolar Generator, which is supposedly capable of ‘taking power from the cosmic energy field which always surrounds us’. Not sure how that process actually works, but that would certainly make it a candidate for a perpetual motion device, wouldn’t it? (left image below):

(images via 1, 2)

Right image above: in the 1980’s, Joseph Newman’s Machine was claimed to produce more power than it needed to operate, one of the qualities usually bundled together with perpetual motion. Apparently, Newman’s machine could charge any batteries it was attached to and work for longer than it would have been able to if only using battery power. However, since it does actually need energy to create additional energy, it isn’t strictly a perpetual motion machine.

The Searl Effect Generator is described as ‘an open system energy-converting machine that uses a drop in temperature in the surrounding air and the device to convert ambient energy to electricity’. Not sure if it actually works, but it looks pretty interesting:

(image via)

"The Searl Effect was discovered by John Roy Robert Searl in 1946. The Searl Effect is based on magnetic waveforms that generates a continual motion of magnetized rollers around magnetized rings. Energy conversion while operating involves processing of random quantum fluctuations and kinetic energy within the atomic lattice into coherent currents of electron pairs formed between two-dimensional boundaries of different type materials." (source)

In Canada, Perepiteia is a perpetual motion device proposed by Thane Heins, making use of electromagnetic force. Tests showed that motors connected to the machine increased their speed and created energy more efficiently, although scientific opinion is still sharply divided about the validity of the project (there is also another one in Ireland):

(images via 1, 2)

China is also building "impossible space drive" (also known as Roger Shawyer’s ‘electromagnetic relativity drive’). It is basically a thruster which uses no fuel except an electricity supply (more info):

(image via)

The Perendev Motor also runs on magnetic force or magnet repulsion. Working models have actually been constructed, admittedly with mixed results, but the theory is considered to be worth pursuing and research continues:

(images via 1, 2)

The idea of perpetual motion and the urge to build the devices capable of overcoming the Second Law of Thermodynamics are very much alive today: it is perhaps quintessential visionary exercise, as much doomed as it is gloriously divine.

"Ouroboros Perpetual Motion Machine", by Austrian artist Otto Rapp, currently residing in Lethbridge, Alberta:

(art by Otto Rapp)



The Rest of Our STEAMPUNK Series ->

Simon Rose is the author of science fiction and fantasy novels for children, including The Alchemist's Portrait, The Sorcerer's Letterbox, The Clone Conspiracy, The Emerald Curse, The Heretic's Tomb and The Doomsday Mask.



Visual Caffeine #8
Visual Caffeine, Issue 8

A thrilling blend of art, myths and technology

Visual Caffeine #7
Visual Caffeine, Issue 7

A thrilling blend of art, myths and technology

Art Deco
Imperial Dreams: Art Deco Update

Wings, Gears, & Glamorous Ladies

1970s SciFi
DRB Pics-of-the-Day

Grand Space Adventure 1970s Art

"Dark Roasted Blend" - All Kinds of Weird and Wonderful Things, Discovered Daily!"

DRB is a top-ranked and respected source for the best in art, travel and fascinating technology, with a highly eclectic presentation. Our in-depth articles in many categories make DRB a valued online magazine, bringing you quality info and entertainment every time you visit the site - About DRB

Connect with us and become part of DRB on Facebook and Twitter.



Anonymous Laurus said...

Part 1 I hope?

Blogger Avi Abrams said...

Correct; let us know tips and links for Part 2. We should be doing this indefinitely, until our perpetual motion engine gives up.

Blogger Daniel said...

The "syphon" attributed to Robert Boyle couldn't be a syphon. Syphons work because the output is lower than the input, allowing the conversion of potential energy to kinetic.

I believe it was an attempt to use the fact that the weight of fluid in the wide part of the funnel is larger than in the thinner part, so (as the theory went) the fluid would be pushed round the loop.

Of course, this is nonsense, since the height of the fluid will equalise between the two arms.

Blogger Mirror507 said...

Perpetual Motion Squad.It reminds me When Escher’s Waterfall Became A Reality On Video.

Anonymous Anonymous said...

to the author and everyone else please research the rodin coil and vortex mathmatics

a good starting place would be here

Anonymous Anonymous said...

The perpetual syphon would totally work as long as the output is small enough to prevent air back into the tube.

Anonymous that guy said...

They missed the best one: the only one that actually works. It has been built and patented, but is not stable enough for commercial use.


Anonymous Anonymous said...

I think this discussion will just go on and on...

Anonymous Anonymous said...

A few years back, reading a 'Wired' mag in the bookstore, there was an article about some older guy who said he could make such a machine, and was experimenting on something that looked like a big ferris wheel, anyone know about that or what happened to it? Guessing it failed or he died since it has not become news, cheers

Blogger Kristophr said...

All of the motor-magnetism perpetual motion machines cooked up recently have one feature in common ... permanent magnets.

They usually generate "free" electricity by slowly degrading the magnetism in the permanent magnets by one means or another.

Power produced is always less than the power required to make the magnets that are expended.

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Vortex math is not a valid area of research. If you are an engineer, mathamatician, or scientist, you would know that the math and science of vortex math have many errors.

Anonymous JMorrison said...

I'd like my invention of a perpetual motion pond water pump/filter judged for plausibility. Better yet to have it fabricated and tested. Mine is the first documented to combine water and magnetic power in the same machine. Link to my blog post detailing the machine: http://ihavenoiqscore.wordpress.com/2012/09/25/gravitymagnet-combined-perpetual-motion-pond-filter-water-pump/

Blogger Ken Behrendt said...

Before dismissing the possibility of a genuine "self-moving" wheel capable of continually outputting mechanical energy, consider this computer model made of a wheel based on the mechanics used by Johann Bessler to make his working wheels back in the early 18th century. As it turns, the center of gravity of its eight weighed levers always stays slightly on the descending side of its axle:



Post a Comment

<< Home

Don't miss: The Ultimate Guide to NEW SF&F Writers!
Fiction Reviews: Classic Cyberpunk: Extreme Fiction
Short Fiction Reviews: Lovecraft's "At the Mountains of Madness" (with pics)
New Fiction Reviews: The Surreal Office


Abandoned, Dieselpunk
DRB Pic-of-the-Day

Abandoned: Streamlined Three-wheeler

Visual Caffeine #6
Visual Caffeine, Issue 6

A thrilling blend of art, myths and technology

Visual Caffeine #5
Visual Caffeine, Issue 5

A thrilling blend of art, myths and technology

Hellish Weather on Other Planets

Wild, Untamed, and Uncut

Medieval Suits of Armor

Metal Body Suits vs. Weapons of Medieval Destruction

World's Strangest Theme Parks

Amusement to the (twisted) extremes!

Enchanting Victorian Fairy Tale Art

"Then world behind and home ahead..."

Adorable Pedal Cars

Collectable Pedal Vehicles Showcase

Japanese Arcades: Gundam Pods & Other Guilty Pleasures

These machines have gone up to the next level

Modernist Tallinn Architecture

Delicious blend of old and new!

Early Supercomputers: A Visual Overview

"Computers in the future may weigh no more than 1.5 tons"

Futuristic Concept Cars of the 1970-80s

French, Italian & Japanese rare beauties

Epic 1970s French Space Comic Art

DRB Time-Slice: Valérian and Laureline

The Trees Are Escaping! The Abandoned Prison in French Guiana

"Great Escape" from the Devil's Island

(with previews, fast loading):


Link Lattes

Feel-Good & Biscotti Issues

Feel-Good! | airplanes | animals | architecture | art | auto | boats | books | cool ads | famous | futurism | food
gadgets | health | japan | internet | link latte | military | music | nature | photo | russia | steampunk
sci-fi & fantasy | signs | space | technology | trains | travel | vintage | weird | abandoned