drb
logo
airplanes | animals | architecture | art | auto | boats | famous | cool ads | funny pics | food | futurism | gadgets | history | japan
military | music | nature | photo | russia | sci-fi | signs | space | sports | steampunk | technology | trains | travel | vintage | weird


Modernist Art in Camouflage


"QUANTUM SHOT" #315
Link



Welcome our contributing writer Constantine vonHoffman of "Collateral Damage" - "Today's sarcasm is tomorrow's news". Constantine is sometime journalist, alleged humorist, award-winning science fiction writer and social media maven for Spoke.com.


Naval fleets once were the largest painting canvases in the world.

War has inspired many great artistic moments but how often have artists returned the favor? Once, as far as I can tell. During World War I Modernism descended on Allied naval planners with a bang (sorry about that), turning fleets into the largest painting canvases in the world.


(image credit: gotouring)


(image credit: lightshipvisual)

HMS "Argus", a World War 1 early aircraft carrier:


(image credit: bobolinkbooks)

Like most of us, The Allies only turned to modern art out of desperation. German U-boats were sinking enormous amounts of shipping and there was no really effective defense against them. It is axiomatic that if you can't stop the people who are shooting at you, you should make it very hard for them to find you. Thus, camouflage.

"War Clover" in color drawing, with a colorized version by Aidan Hall:




(images credit: Jim and Jamie Richter)

(As hard as it may be to believe, camouflage was still a radical idea in military circles at the outset of WWI. At the start of the war, four Zouave regiments of the French Army were outfitted in bright blue jackets and red pants. Neither this uniform nor the men wearing them lasted very long.)


(image credit: Imperial War Museum)

Most camouflage is based on the idea of concealment and blending in with its surroundings. However another school of thought has argued for making the item in question appear to be a mashup of unrelated components. Naval camoufleurs found this theory particularly appealing. Blending didn't work because ships operated in two different and constantly changing color environments – sea and sky. Any camo that concealed in one environment was usually spectacularly conspicuous in others.

Hard to tell where the ship is heading

Norman Wilkinson, a British naval officer and painter, suggested a scheme that came to be known as Dazzle or Razzle Dazzle painting. Wilkinson believed that breaking up a ship's silhouette with brightly contrasting geometric designs would make it harder for U-boat captains to determine the ship's course.





SS "Argylshire":



The French cruiser "Gloire":


(image credit: Jim and Jamie Richter)

The SS "Melita":


(image credit: Jim and Jamie Richter)

USS "Mahomet":


(images credit: Jim and Jamie Richter)

USS "Leviathan":






(images credit: history.navy.mil)

Passenger liners join the gallery

Even passenger liners were camouflaged in the similar radical way. HMS "Mauritania", apparently inspired by Pagliacci:






(artist Burnett Poole, 1919)




You can paint, but you can't hide

How well did it work? How well do most artistic theories work when they confront the real world? While there was a marked decrease in losses to U-boats après Dazzle, historians agree that this reduction was mainly due to the adoption of the convoy system at the same time. Dazzle did, however, boost the morale of allied seamen as well as capture the imagination of artists and the public alike.

Had the Allies been fighting art history majors or Academy painters there is little doubt they would have been stunned into submission by the sheer audacity of the color schemes. The only way these designs would have confused the U-boat captains was if the sky and sea had been created by Mondrian or Duchamp.

While full color Razzle Dazzle never really succeeded, its easy to see its impact in later successful camouflage. The German Navy tossed out the garish color schemes and used geometric painting in black, white and gray during World War II. Other navies continue to use variations on this to this day.

The German battleship "Tirpitz"





DD-541, The Destroyer "Yarnall":



US Navy cruiser "Alaska":



USS "Charles S. Sperry"


(image credit: John Prolly)

Here is an example of the Russian ship camouflage:




Artistic versions of Razzle-Dazzle paint schemes

Unfortunately there are no known color photographs of these ships. Contemporary accounts describe them as every bit as breath-taking as one would imagine them to be. It is fitting that the best representations we have of the Razzle Dazzle ships are done by painters.

"A Convoy", 1918, by Herbert Barnard John Everett:


(image credit: nmm.ac.uk)

"Dazzle Ship in Drydock" by Edward Wadsworth, 1919:



Painting of HMS "Olympic", sister ship of the "Titanic", in its
wartime mufti by Arthur Lismer:


(image credit: julesverne.ca)

Another view of the "Olympic":



L. Campbell Taylor drew "Mauretania" with a checkerboard pattern:


(image credit: bobolinkbooks)


(image credit: Jim and Jamie Richter)

"Dockyard, Portsmouth" by J.D.Fergusson, 1918:




Dazzling Camo for Infantry


German Steel Helmet & Gloves, First World War

It's easy to mock the idea of Razzle Dazzle colorful outfits for soldiers during World War I. However, the digital camouflage used by many armies today seems to owe something to Dazzle's geometric schemes. Digital camo uses small micropatterns, as opposed to larger macropatterns – like drawings of trees or leafs. (more info here)




Dazzle has also had significant impact throughout the world of art.

Fiat Strada painted in dazzle design by Patricia van Lubeck, 1990:


Courtesy DPM. Photo: Patricia van Lubeck

Graphic by Kenzo Minami:


(image credit: John Prolly)

Military historians have usually connected Razzle Dazzle with cubism, which is patently wrong. It is quite clearly inspired by Vorticism, which is considered to be the only significant British art movement of the early 20th century. Started by Wyndham Lewis, editor of the short-lived "Blast" magazine, Vorticism was much more confrontational than Cubism.


(source: Wiki commons)

The Cubist was concerned with apples, guitars and life in the cafe. The Vorticist was not afraid of looking outside the cafe and observing the architecture which surrounded the cafe. Also, there was a hint of aggression, or conflict in most Vorticist works that is entirely missing in French work. Vorticist works are characterised by the unease created by a disrupted perspective. (more info here) Given that description which artistic theory would you rather use to cover your ship?

Postscript –

This was not the oddest attempt to disguise ships.

That honor goes to another Brit: Lord Mountbatten. In 1940 then Capt. Mountbatten was in charge of a convoy of ships. He noticed that one ship in the group disappeared from view earlier that the other ships. That ship was a Union Castle liner that was still wearing her pre-war hull color of medium lavender mauve grey.



Mountbatten thought this color would be particularly effective at dawn and dusk, often the times of greatest danger for ships. He had all destroyers in his flotilla painted in the color, which came to be known as Mountbatten pink. (more info here)


(image credit: James Dorrian)


Ship disguised as a tropical island

A special kind of camouflage was employed by the Dutch warship Abraham Crijnssen. Originally built in 1936 as a minesweeper, this ship was stationed in the former Dutch East Indies in 1937. At the outbreak of the Second World War "Abraham Crijnssen" made its escape from the Japanese invading forces in a truly spectacular way.

Camouflaged as tropical island (!) the ship sailed between enemy lines to
Australia. From there the "Abraham Crijnssen" undertook patrol and convoy services until the end of the war.





(Source: Allies in Adversity, thanks Martijn Reneman)

REQUIRED READING: "The Great War and Modern Memory" by Paul Fussel.
The pre-eminent study of World War I and it's impact on the world's artistic vision. Superb.

All World War I photos on this page are from the museum catalog "Dazzle Painting, Kunst als Camouflage, Camouflage als Kunst", by Albert Roskam / Stichting kunstprojecten, 1987, public domain

Article by Constantine vonHoffman of "Collateral Damage" and Avi Abrams for Dark Roasted Blend.
(want to be our contributing writer? contact us, see guidelines here)

+StumbleUpon

Permanent Link...
Category: Art,Military, Boats/Ships
Related Posts: Tank Bling!, Jets & Clouds Effects



RECENT ARTICLES:


These Glorious Three-Wheeled Microcars

Jellybean Three-Wheelers! (Who Needs an Extra Wheel?)

DRB Feel-Good
DRB Feel-Good Issue #19

Loads of cool and rare imagery


Japan Robot Restaurant: Totally Over-the-Top!

Probably the craziest restaurant in the entire world



"Dark Roasted Blend" - All Kinds of Weird and Wonderful Things, Discovered Daily!"

DRB is a top-ranked and respected source for the best in art, travel and fascinating technology, with a highly visual presentation. Our in-depth articles in many categories make DRB a highly visual online magazine, bringing you quality entertainment every time you open your "feed" reader or visit our site - About DRB

Connect with us and become part of DRB on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, Google Plus; make sure to subscribe to our updates.

Our mobile site: http://mobile.darkroastedblend.com. You can also read us on iPad, as part of the Flipboard popular free app.



YOUR COMMENTS::

23 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

As fas as I am concerned, camouflage is applied to equipments in order to avoid being noticed.

___  
Blogger Skipweasel said...

The British army used pink for desert patrol vehicles during the Second World War and continued to do so for some time after. Not just slightly pink, either, but /very/ pink. They were known as Pink Panthers.

http://www.4wdonline.com/Museums/BMIHT/PinkPanther.html

___  
Anonymous Slow Joe Crow said...

One of the primary objectives of dazzle camouflage was to prevent effective use of optical rangefinders. It was also important to confuse observers as to course and speed so many camo schemes incorporated false bow waves or false bow and stern outlines.
As an aside, sometimes camouflage can be too good. The multi color scheme developed for the Denny Steam Gunboats in WWII was so good that two gunboats ran into each other while on patrol because neither one saw the other.

___  
Blogger Curse You Khan! said...

Pink is a popular color in the military. Robyn Miller, co-creator of the game Myst, has a truly wonderful article on other pink military vehicles here.
http://tinselman.typepad.com/tinselman/2006/04/war_pink_peace.html

___  
Blogger Liz said...

I need to repaint my bedroom, and Medium Lavender Mauve Grey looks just the ticket. Hurrah for battleships.

Bedrooms aside, dazzle camouflage actually turns out to have been pretty effective, as slow joe crow points out. It was meant to confuse rather than conceal, and did its job very well. (After all - we did *win*.) Many of those patterns created one or more fake bows, which confused submarine periscopes trying to aim for the ship's weakest spot. I do wonder whether the general designs chosen would have been different if the prevailing artistic movement at the time hadn't been modernism (and if you look at paintings by people like Bawden and Ravilious you can absolutely see where those boldly hatched patterns came from aesthetically).

___  
Blogger Avi Abrams said...

thanks for all that info... pink is the best camouflage in the desert. Goes well with tanks, too.

___  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

FAKE, just a photoshop geek gone wild. Just kidding, somebody had to say it.

___  
Anonymous mrmule said...

Dutch graffiti artist 'Delta Inc' has produced a Dazzle Be@rbrick for the Kubrick toy range.

http://www.mrmule.com/archives/2005/02/kubrick_jest_de.html

___  
Anonymous mrmule said...

DELTA INC 'DAZZLE' BE@RBRICK

___  
Blogger Curse You Khan! said...

They will definitely have a hard time being hit by torpedoes.

BTW, we have received some emails pointing out that we misidentified the HMS Argus as the HMS Sargus. I'm sticking to my theory that this, too, was part of the camo.

___  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

WELL , I THINK THAT THE CAR WITH THE DAZZLE PAINTWORK IS AN OPEL KADETT , NOT A FIAT STRADA .

___  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

..the dazzle effect , effected to the
opel kadett , transforming it into a fiat strada !!!

___  
Blogger Dom said...

Avi, the picture caption that reads 'The HMS "Sargus"' should say 'HmS Argus'. HMS, standing for His (or Her) Majesty's Ship, does not have 'the' in front of it.

Is this the best camouflage in the world? I think so!

___  
Blogger Curse You Khan! said...

actually popular usage has made "HMS So So" totally acceptable.

___  
Blogger Dom said...

Not sure if that last comment was meant as a contradiction, but just to clarify: no-one would say "the Her Majesty's Ship Whatever visited port today", and even if "popular usage" saw a lot of people abusing the language in that way, it would not suddenly make it acceptable :-P

___  
Blogger Avi Abrams said...

Dom, article adjusted, thanks

___  
Blogger Riceball said...

I always thought that dazzleflage was pretty cool to look at and something that might serve a useful purpose today. Watching a program on sharks a while back some scientists conducted an experiment where they tossed two pieces of wood, one shaped like a seal and one a square. Naturally the shark attacked the seal shape but pretty much ignored the square because it didn't look natural. Imagine if you were to do a dazzle pattern on a wetsuit and/or the bottom of a surfboard and actually make it visible when viewed from below I wonder if it would help to prevent surfers and snorklers from being mistaken for seals by sharks since their outlines would be completely broken up and look completely unnatural to a hungry shark.

___  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Well, sharks also have alternative ways to hunt you down. Not that it wouldn't still help.

___  
Blogger Jon said...

I don;t think you did all your homework on this one. The British Admiraly studied Dazzle painting after WW1 and was unable to find one incident in which is helped throw off a U boat torp. Thus they declared it a failure.

However, it had an interesting secondary impact in that it provided a major morale boost to the sailors on the ship (thinking they were safer). Thus they kept doing it for that reason alone.

So, no. The official Royal Navy report says that it was NOT effective.

___  
Blogger Dom said...

Not entirely true, Jon. The Brits couldn’t prove it worked, but they found it didn’t make the vessels more of a target, either, so as it didn’t do any harm, and could be said to be a morale booster, as you mention, it was kept. Proving its effectiveness was always going to be difficult though – the idea was to prevent or delay an attack in the first place, not throw the submarine’s aim off. Since a vessel would have had no idea it was being targeted until it saw torpedo tracks in the water, the Admiralty could only measure reports of actual attacks, not attempts.

Conversely, the US Navy decided Dazzle WAS effective!

___  
Blogger arnver said...

Gosh this is so Fernand Leger! Haha. I'm stunned.

___  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

An additional comment. Warfare did not originally mean concealment. Both land and naval forces clearly announced their presence before battle by flags and banners. Only after trench warfare became the order of the day, did camouflage become standard. Compare any Civil War Movie with any WWII movie. One has armies marching in formation towards each other, the other has small groups sneaking up on each other. Different uniforms for different tactics. Ditto for Naval forces. Zouave units were formed in honor of Algerian infantry which had covered itself with glory. There were many Zouave units in the Civil War on both sides. They were considered elite units, much like paratroop or special forces,wearing berets rather than helmets. When weapons became long range so warfare was no longer face to face, camouflage became important. As mentioned, the dazzle pattern also confused range finding, there was no radar or sonar, only optical range finders. So correct focus was very important, but the dazzle made it difficult to focus correctly making accurate range estimates impossible. By WWII, 16 inch naval guns had a range of 25 miles. The visual horizon is 6 to 12 miles, depending on how high above sea level you are.

___  
Blogger Avi Abrams said...

Thank you for this insightful comment - big guns changed everything, indeed

___  

Post a Comment

<< Home


SF ART & BOOK REVIEWS:
Don't miss: The Ultimate Guide to NEW SF&F Writers!
Fiction Reviews: Classic Cyberpunk: Extreme Fiction
Short Fiction Reviews: Lovecraft's "At the Mountains of Madness" (with pics)
New Fiction Reviews: The Surreal Office



READ OTHER RECENT ARTICLES:



Nightmare Playgrounds, Part 2
Nightmare Playgrounds, Part 1

Seriously disturbing sculptures, meant for kids


Nightmare Playgrounds, Part 3

When trapped in a nightmare, enjoy a kiddie-slide!


Cars with Propellers, Part 2

Futuristic "Pillbug", built in 1936 in Germany


DRB Pic-of-the-Day: Shire on Earth

Found! The secret hideout of hobbits


Cars with Propellers, Part 1

Essential steampunk transportation


Super-Colorful Rivers

Rivers full of heavenly colour


Let's "Go!": Ancient Chinese Game Boards

A long, passionate duel... with less victory


Surprised Astronauts (Funny Pics)

"My God, it's full of stars!"


Antique Digital Calculators & Other Steampunk Gear

You know you want these retro masterpieces


Spectacular & Mysterious Lightning, Part 1

Wild heavenly unrest and hair-raising electrical storms


Toy Robots to Have and to Hold

Share your life with a bunch of cute Japanese toy robots!


Imperial Dreams: Art Deco Update

Soviet Unique Glass Holders, and more


Flying Colors! Creative Paint on Airliners

"Art planes" to pretty up the skies


Gorgeous Espresso Machines

Awesome steam: retro & modern examples


DRB History Issue: World War Two

Soviet Female Fighter Pilots of the WW2


Thrilling Vintage Movie Posters

Spewed from Intergalactic Space!..


Cosmonaut's Bling!

Under the banner of Lenin - to the stars!


Crazy (and Dangerous) Railroads

Landslide on an Old Harrowing Railroad


Enchanting Waterfall Island

Like the Nagrand region in World of Warcraft

DRB Feel-Good
DRB Feel-Good Issue #16

Loads of cool and rare imagery


Auto Oops! Bizarre Car Accidents, Part 7

New batch of maddeningly mysterious wrecks


Mind-Blowing Optical Illusions, Part 6

"The soul has illusions as the bird has wings: it is supported by them"


Exceptional British 1950s Scifi Artwork

Quintessential Space Pulp Art by Ron Turner and others


FULL ARCHIVES (with previews, fast loading):

June 2014 --
May 2014 -- April 2014 -- Feb-March 2014 -- January 2014 -- Oct-Dec 2013 --
September 2013 -- August 2013 -- July 2013 -- May-June 2013 -- April 2013 --
March 2013 -- February 2013 -- Dec-Jan 2013 --
November 2012 -- October 2012 -- September 2012 --
August 2012 -- July 2012 -- June 2012 -- May 2012 -- April 2012 --
March 2012 -- February 2012 -- Dec-Jan 2012 --
November 2011 -- October 2011 -- September 2011 --
August 2011 -- July 2011 -- June 2011 --
May 2011 -- April 2011 -- March 2011 --
February 2011 -- January 2011 -- December 2010 --
November 2010 -- October 2010 -- September 2010 --
August 2010 - July 2010 -- June 2010 --
May 2010 -- April 2010 -- March 2010 --
Winter 2009-2010 -- Oct-Nov 2009 -- September 2009 --
August 2009 -- June-July 2009 -- May 2009 --
April 2009 -- March 2009 -- February 2009 --
January 2009 -- December 2008 -- November 2008 --
October 2008 -- September 2008 -- August 2008 --
July 2008 -- June 2008 -- May 2008 --
April 2008 -- March 2008 -- February 2008 --
January 2008 -- Dec, 2007 -- November 2007 --
October 2007 -- September 2007 -- August 2007 --
July 2007 -- June 2007 -- May 2007 --
April 2007 -- March 2007 -- February 2007 --
January 2007 -- December 2006 -- November 2006 --
October 2006 -- Link Latte Issues -- Biscotti Issues



CATEGORIES:
airplanes | animals | architecture | art | auto | boats | books | cool ads | funny pics | famous | futurism | food
gadgets | health | history | humour | japan | internet | link latte | military | music | nature | photo | russia | steampunk
sci-fi & fantasy | signs | space | sports | technology | trains | travel | vintage | weird




















Airplanes
Animals
Architecture
Art
Auto
Boats
Computers
Cool Ads
Extreme Weather
Food
Funny Pics
Futurism
Gadgets
History
Humour
Link Latte
Military
Music
Nature
Oops Accidents
Photography
Robots
Science
Science Fiction

Space
Sports
Technology
Trains
Travel
UE Abandoned
Vintage
Weird













Avi Abrams
Rachel Abrams
M. Christian
Simon Rose
Paul Schilperoord
Scott Seegert
Constantine vonHoffman


Send us your topic ideas, site suggestions, rants or sweet unpublished poetry. We love to hear from you.

Samsung Galaxy Case friendly.